Welcome to EDP24 Forums | EDP24 Home | Forums | Sign in | Join | Settings
 

Print Search
Sort Posts:    
   16/09/2007, 1:50 PM
Jeff Taylor is not online. Last active: 21/07/2008 16:55:06 Jeff Taylor

Not Ranked
Joined on 04/11/2005
Wymondham, Norfolk
Posts 37
THE RINGS OF SATURN BY W.G.SEBALD Introduction EDP SUNDAY 15th September 2007

When I told an acquaintance that I was considering having W.G. Sebalds’s The Rings of Saturn as this month’s Book Club choice he said that it might inspire him to find his copy, vacuum it down and read it ‘at last’. I didn’t confess that my own copy had been gloomily waiting on a shelf in our bathroom since I first bought it in 2001 after hearing of the author’s death in a local  car accident.

 

Prior to his death W.G. Sebald  had been Professor of Modern German Literature at the University of East  Anglia and the founding director of the British Centre for Literary Translation.  He was born in Bavaria in 1944, studied literature in Germany, Switzerland and Manchester where he became assistant lecturer in 1966 and settled in England permanently in 1970 when he moved to UEA.

 

Most descriptions of Sebald’s writing   concentrate on the theme of memory  and his attempt to reconcile himself with the trauma of the Second World War, its effect on the German psyche and his use of a mixture of ‘fact, recollection and fiction’. His books are interspersed with black and white photographs which ‘are set in evocative counterpoint to the narrative rather than illustrating it directly.’  Several  of  the narrative linked images in The Rings of  Saturn are of Sir Thomas Browne, the 17th  century  physician, philosopher, botanist who had a deep interest in the natural world. He is the subject of the controversial and complex £2000,000  sculpture on Hay Hill in Norwich.

 

Andrew Motion has described The Rings of Saturn, in a review mentioned further on,  as ‘a descriptive ramble along the edge of East Anglia… interspersed with more or less freestanding reflections on characters and ideas’ and which the  reviewer believes ‘has its roots in late 19th-and early 20th-century travelogues…’  

 

All this makes Sebald’s book  sound quite difficult and a bit obscure  and is probably why his book has stayed unread on at least two sets of book shelves and possibly many more. 

 

I was however inspired to suggest the book as a Book Club choice  by  seeing  Waterlog an exhibition, partly invoked by  The Rings of Saturn,  which was held in Norwich during the summer of 2007 and  which drew ‘ upon the profound sense of place of the landscape of East Anglia…composed of a series of actual and imaginary journeys.’ About the same time I read a  review by Andrew Motion  of   Robert Macfarlane's The Wild Places a recently published  description of  the author’s  tour of Britain's remotest parts. In the review, Motion  comments that Mafarlane’s method ‘owes an obvious debt’  to  The Rings of Saturn.

 

I’ve been reading The Wild Places and  am dipping into Roger Deakin’s Waterlog (no direct connection to the exhibition) which describes his experiences of 'wild swimming' through  Britain's rivers and lakes while commenting on the degradation of Britian’s waterways.  So, as a coping mechanism,  The Rings of Saturn, which I admit is not an easy read, will be going into the present mix of my  ‘topographical’ reading.   Might take a while though as it’s staying in the bathroom - hopefully not to get waterlogged.

 

Jeff


   Report 
   09/10/2007, 10:53 AM
K Gardener is not online. Last active: 20/05/2008 08:37:23 K Gardener

Not Ranked
Joined on 01/03/2007
Posts 10
Re: THE RINGS OF SATURN BY W.G.SEBALD Introduction EDP SUNDAY 15th September 2007

I was interested in the comparisons being made between W Sebald’s The Rings of Saturn and the works of  Edward Thomas, Robert & Roger Deakin in  the book club column and reiterated with the inclusion of Mark Cocker and Richard Mabey  in last weekend’s SUNDAY features by Keiron Pim and Ian Collins.  In my opinion Edward Thomas and Roger Deakin are  the most accessible with their  obvious passion  and concern for the natural world stated simply and without pretension.  Robert  MacFarlane  is slightly precious but still entertaining  in his description  of  feelings that most people take for granted.  Mark Cocker I haven’t yet started to read but  I am concerned at the increasing literary slightly pompous style of  the writings of   Richard Mabey in his recent Narrative of Trees.  Sebald is however in a world of his own, literally.

 

The Rings of Saturn is  stream of academic consciousness apparently unmediated by  any attempt to make his writing/thought  accessible to anyone else apart from his colleagues in the academic world. I’m afraid I came away with the impression of a man travelling around in a mobile ivory tower.  

 

As Jeff mentioned in his introduction last month Sebald goes into some detail about the life of the physician, philosopher et al Sir Robert Browne and I found this quite interesting knowing almost nothing about him.  Unfortunately  Browne is even more academic and obscure than Sebald.

 

I think there is some irony in the fact that however difficult I find  Sebald’s book  I didn’t have  to buy it but  representations of Sir Thomas Browne’s obscure academic work  were  imposed on the topography of Norwich in the form of various expensive bits of stone.  I wonder what J B Priestly, a writer totally lacking in any of the pretensions and preciousness of today’s traveloguers and public artists and who journeyed to Norwich over seventy years ago,    would make of  the spending of £200,000 on uncomfortable seats for customers of Macdonalds however full their minds might be of  the   Quincunx!


   Report 
   09/10/2007, 11:38 AM
K Gardener is not online. Last active: 20/05/2008 08:37:23 K Gardener

Not Ranked
Joined on 01/03/2007
Posts 10
Re: THE RINGS OF SATURN BY W.G.SEBALD Introduction EDP SUNDAY 15th September 2007

Sorry didn't  read my response properly. Where I wrote 'Robert & Roger Deakin'   in first paragraph it was obviously meant to read 'Robert Macfarlane & Roger Deakin'

 

Kate


   Report 
   16/10/2007, 12:26 PM
Jeff Taylor is not online. Last active: 21/07/2008 16:55:06 Jeff Taylor

Not Ranked
Joined on 04/11/2005
Wymondham, Norfolk
Posts 37
Re: THE RINGS OF SATURN BY W.G.SEBALD Introduction EDP SUNDAY 15th September 2007
I dont think Sebald should just be dismissed as an obscure  academic. I think he is difficult because he brings his  mind to  the landscape unlike Mabey etc who bring the landscape to their mind. There is an obituary by Sebalds friend the late Eric Homburger on the Guardian Archive website (Monday Dec 17 2001) which helped me when reading The Rings of Saturn.
   Report 
EDP24 Forums » EDP24 Features » EDP Book Club » THE RINGS OF SATURN BY W.G.SEBALD Introduction EDP SUNDAY 15th September 2007

Powered by Community Server, by Telligent Systems

Copyright © 2007 Archant Regional Limited. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditions